Mar 28, 2023
Here’s How Much Top US Polluters Must Cut Methane to Avoid Fees
(Bloomberg) -- Endeavor Energy Resources must slash its US methane releases more than any other major emitter to avoid penalties that come into force next year, according to an analysis from BloombergNEF that examined how new rules impact the 10 biggest polluters of the greenhouse gas.
The report shows just how much work some of the world’s most prolific oil and gas producers must do to clean up releases of the potent greenhouse gas, which has more than 80 times the warming power of carbon dioxide during its first two decades in the atmosphere. Halting releases of methane, the primary component of natural gas, could do more to slow climate change than almost any other single measure.
Closely held Endeavor, which is based in the heart of the Permian Basin in Midland, Texas, must reduce its onshore methane releases 80% by 2024 to avoid the fines, which are part of the Inflation Reduction Act, according to the BNEF analysis. Diversified Energy Co. and Chesapeake Energy Corp. rounded out the top three and must cut emissions 67% and 61%, respectively.
Representatives for Endeavor and Chesapeake didn't immediately respond to emailed requests for comment. Diversified said in a statement that its leak detection and repair initiatives are making methane releases rare on its network and that it expects to avoid fees through reductions and compliance “without material change to our ongoing emissions reduction investment program.’’
As methane emissions have exploded globally over the last few years — increasingly posing a direct threat to global climate goals — governments have stepped up efforts to curb releases of the invisible, odorless gas from the agriculture, energy and waste sectors. More than 100 countries have signed the US and European Union-led Global Methane Pledge, which aims to slash releases 30% by the end of this decade from 2020 levels.
But cuts by fossil fuel companies aren’t on pace to meet those goals. Releases from oil, gas and coal operators reached 120 million metric tons in 2022, just short of a record set in 2019, according to the International Energy Agency’s Methane Tracker report. Globally, oil and gas companies together emit nearly the equivalent of the massive Nord Stream release on average every day.
BNEF found that the cost of cleaning up methane releases at US onshore operations is small for most of the 10 largest polluters. For instance, Endeavor would need to spend just $31 million, or about 1.1% of its 2022 upstream capital expenditures, for mitigation efforts like replacing pneumatic pumps that the energy researcher said would cut its methane emissions by 18,000 tons and allow it to avoid fees. ConocoPhillips, which had the highest projected costs to curb leaks at $117 million, would need to spend the equivalent of just 1.2% of its upstream capital expenditures last year.
Representatives for Endeavor and ConocoPhillips did not immediately respond outside normal business hours in the US to questions about capital expenditures.An exception was Diversified Energy, for whom the estimated $68 million needed to clean up its operations is equivalent to 79% of its capital expenditures last year. The company was the focus on a Bloomberg investigation in 2021 that found widespread gas leaks at its aging production installations.
The new fees start at $900 per ton in 2024 before increasing to $1,200 and $1,500 in the following two years. The payouts are collected in the year after they are assessed and only apply for methane emissions that exceed activity-specific thresholds.
In total, the top 10 US emitters, which include global energy majors Exxon Mobil Corp. and TotalEnergies SE, would need to spend a combined $426 million by 2024 on abatement technologies to reduce their methane emissions enough to be exempt from the fees, the BNEF analysis showed. Aside from the climate benefits of halting leaks, the changes could also boost profit and offer a competitive advantage.
Around 40% of the methane emissions from oil and gas between 2017 and 2019 could have been avoided at no net cost because the additional gas that is captured can be sold, boosting revenues, according to the IEA. Producing hydrocarbons with a lower emissions intensity also offers a competitive sales advantage because the fuel has a lower climate impact, said Maria-Olivia Torcea, the report’s author and an analyst at BNEF.
TotalEnergies said it has plans in place to reduce methane venting emissions by approximately 7,000 tons a year by the end of 2024. As a result of such programs, it expects methane emissions from its operations to be below the IRA threshold, according to a company spokeswoman.EQT, the largest US gas producer, is forecast to be exempt from the new fees because the company’s methane intensity is below the 0.2% emissions threshold set out under the rules. EQT started replacing gas-driven pneumatic devices 18 months ago and has spent $20 million replacing the equipment, according to the report.
(Updates story published on March 28 with comments from TotalEnergies in penultimate paragraph)
©2023 Bloomberg L.P.