Feb 1, 2023
Brazil Keeps Rates as Spat With Lula Fuels Inflation Bets
(Bloomberg) -- Brazil’s real strengthened to the highest since June after central bankers kept interest rates on hold and expressed concern about rising inflation expectations, fueled by tensions with President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva’s new government.
Policymakers held the benchmark Selic at 13.75% for the fourth straight meeting late on Wednesday, as expected. But the statement was widely seen as hawkish, with board members writing they will assess if keeping rates steady “for a longer period” than previously expected will slow inflation to target.
“The current scenario, particularly uncertain on the fiscal side and with inflation expectations drifting away from the inflation target on longer horizons, requires further attention when evaluating risks,” they wrote. “The Committee judges that this scenario raises the cost of the disinflation that is needed to reach the targets” established for the years ahead.
The Brazilian real was the best performer among emerging-market currencies Thursday, gaining as much as 2.2% against the dollar. It strengthened past 5 reais per dollar for the first time since June. Swap rates on the contract due in January 2024, which indicate market expectations for monetary policy at the end of this year, jumped ten basis points.
“Investors are giving a lot of credibility to the central bank,” said Sergio Zanini, a partner at Galapagos Capital. “Their statement was important to defend its mandate and its independence.”
Policymakers led by Roberto Campos Neto are battling rising cost-of-living expectations that make it more difficult to justify rate cuts, even as annual inflation has consistently eased over the past few months — to 5.87% from last year’s peak of more than 12%. The decline has been driven by tax cuts and restrictive borrowing costs, but fuel prices are now going up while core measures that strip out the most volatile items are accelerating.
Read More: Lula Squandered Rate Cut Chance, His Ex-Central Bank Chief Says
What Bloomberg Economics Says
“Officials referred to the strategy of holding rates for longer than what’s assumed in its forecasts, i.e. consensus projections. We think that’s an attempt to sound hawkish without suggesting a rate hike. Currently, the consensus forecast is for the first rate cut to come in September. The statement language suggests it may come later.”
— Adriana Dupita, Brazil and Argentina economist
Click here for full report
The decision comes amid political tensions after Lula questioned the central bank’s independence and its inflation goals, suggesting it should pursue a 4.5% target. Currently, the bank targets price increases of 3.25% for 2023 and 3% for the next two years.
Finance Minister Fernando Haddad added to speculation that policies may change, saying that Brazil needs ambitious, yet feasible targets.
Investors are also fretting about the fiscal outlook, as Haddad is expected to propose new spending rules by April, replacing the current law that limits public expenditure increases to the prior year’s inflation rate. The new government is also deploying 168 billion reais ($33 billion) in additional spending, including social aid, while weighing a higher minimum wage.
“The statement is hawkish,” said Felipe Sichel, economist and partner at Modal Asset Management Ltda. “It leaves the door open to keeping rates steady for a longer period and clearly warns about worsening inflation expectations.”
Sichel added that he sees no borrowing-cost cuts this year.
In the statement, board members wrote that expectations for consumer price increases “have shown deterioration at longer horizons.” Meanwhile, the global economy remains under inflationary pressure despite positive signs at the margin, they wrote.
Earlier on Wednesday, the Federal Reserve slowed the pace of rate rises but said more increases are in store. Regionally, policymakers from Mexico to Colombia continue to hike, while Chile’s central bank President Rosanna Costa has pushed back against investor bets of the start of an easing cycle.
In an outlook considering rate cuts starting in September as shown in its weekly economist survey, Brazil’s central bank sees consumer price increases above the ceiling of its tolerance range in 2023 and above target next year. In an alternative scenario with a constant Selic, inflation forecasts stand lower, at 5.5% for this year and 2.8% for next.
In the outlook with steady borrowing costs, “inflation is closer to the 3% target in 2024,” said Leonardo Costa, an economist at Asa Investments. “That indicates the central bank’s plan is to keep rates steady for a longer period.”
Meanwhile, analysts see consumer prices rising above the bank’s mid-term goal for the foreseeable future. Officials will set the 2026 target this year.
“The statement was extremely harsh,” said Carla Argenta, chief economist at CM Capital. “The central bank understands that, under current conditions, we don’t have inflationary convergence, and that the institution should make some change in its monetary policy or keep rates steady for longer.”
--With assistance from Giovanna Serafim, Raphael Almeida Dos Santos, Josue Leonel and Philip Sanders.
(Recasts story with market moves)
©2023 Bloomberg L.P.
BNN Bloomberg Picks
Energy stocks to hold for the long haul: Three hot picks from Cole Smead
Margaret Franklin on rebranding finance as a career for women
Powell hedged his bet of a soft landing: Larry Berman
Is your retirement portfolio ready for what's to come?
Investment opportunities in cannabis stocks: Three hot picks from Matt Bottomley
What happens if you mistakenly get a larger tax refund?